Spaghetti Sauce

Your kids will think you have gone off the deep end when you serve them WORMS for dinner!

And you will be patting yourself on the back because it is SO EASY and super cheap too! BOOM.

The “trick” ingredient is Wilton icing color.

It is easily accessible at craft stores like JoAnn’s, Hobby Lobby or at Walmart for only around $1.75 per bottle. (Check Brickseek to see if your Walmart has it in stock!)

If you don’t want to hunt it down at a brick & mortar store, you can get it on Amazon for $4.99 with prime.


Scariest Spaghetti Sauce Dinner Supplies:

  • Wilton Black Icing Color
  • Spaghetti Noodles
  • Spaghetti Sauce
  • Pimento Filled Olives
Spaghetti Sauce

Step 1: Add Coloring

To the pot of water that you are going to add the noodles too, add 1/2 teaspoon of black icing color before the water starts to boil.


Save Money On Your Craft Supplies

Download this FREE Guide to find 25 Ways to save money when you buy craft supplies so that your beautiful creations cost less.

Spaghetti Sauce

Step 2: Cook Noodles & Drain

Cook regular size spaghetti noodles according to package directions.

Drain as the noodles into a colander in the sink.

Be careful to slowly pour the water out of the pot into the sink as to not splash or stain your clothing.

Spaghetti Sauce

Step 3: Rinse Sink

This is more of a precautionary measure, but be sure to rinse the sink right away so it won’t stain.

Spaghetti Sauce

Step 4: Add Spaghetti Sauce And Assemble Scary Plate

Pile a heap of scary blackworm spaghetti to a plate.

Add the meat sauce and two pimento filled olives for eerie eyes.

BOOM! You’ve got a scary wormy spaghetti sauce dinner your kids will love!

Keep the fun going by reading a scary story during dinner.

Stir up a batch of Spooky Punch and let the fun never end!


Your Turn: Have you tried making the Scariest Spaghetti Sauce Dinner? Let me know what how much fun you had with your dinner by commenting below!